The Aerodrome Home Page
Aces of WWI
Aircraft of WWI
Books and Film
The Aerodrome Forum
Sign the Guestbook
Help
Links to Other Sites
Medals and Decorations
The Aerodrome News
Search The Aerodrome
Today in History


Learn how to remove ads

The Aerodrome Forum


Go Back   The Aerodrome Forum > Archives > 1999


1999 Closed threads from 1999 (read only)

 
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 24 September 1999, 03:27 AM   #1 (permalink)
Kory Clark
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
That never got me and answer the first time.

Why Is Alan MacLeod :

http://www.accessweb.com/users/mconstab/mcleod.htm

Not list in any ace lists? 6 Kills makes an ace, or so I thought? Esp. since his is somewhat high profile. (Won Victoria Cross)

Anyone have a clue why he is not listed as an ace?

Last time I asked the whole OOC thing got pinned on him by some forumites, that's so weak, lots of 5-6 kill aces have ooc victories.



 
Old 24 September 1999, 04:09 AM   #2 (permalink)
Forum Ace
 
Lufbery's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 1999
Location: Harrisburg, PA
Posts: 2,566
 
I had sorta the same question about A. S. G. Lee. He even says in No Parachute that he had five or six kills but was a long way from being an ace. Does anybody know the story behind that?

-Drew
__________________
Drew Ames

"Drew can talk -- by Jove, how the man can talk!" -- James Norman Hall in "High Adventure"
Lufbery is offline  
Old 24 September 1999, 04:22 AM   #3 (permalink)
Forum Ace
 
Michael's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 1998
Location: Oakville Ontario
Posts: 1,126
 
Just a thought, but I seem to recall from my reading that at the time the RFC/RAF while not officially recognizing "Ace" status, thought that it kicked in at ten "victories" (to use a neutral term).
__________________
Adjt. Antonin Dominique Barthélèmy Gautier
Médaille Militaire, Croix de Guerre - SPA 80
October 2, 1895-September 15, 1918
Mort pour la France en combat aérien.
Michael is offline  
Old 24 September 1999, 05:03 AM   #4 (permalink)
Jasta 8
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Hi Kirby,

As absurd as 75% of Allied victory confirmations were, not all OOC's were stamped confirmed carte blanche - although many were! I have a library of over 800 books written on the air war of WWI and not one acknowledges either Alan Mac Leod or Arthur Gould Lee as an ace. Remember Arch Whitehouse claimed 16 in his long "storied" career.

Alan Mac Leod was a very brave man who had the bad luck of getting shot to pieces by an up and coming
Hans Kirstein in an antiquated ill-equipped two-seater. He was adequately and appropriately compensated with his VC. No need to embelish any further.

VBR,

Jasta 8
 
Old 24 September 1999, 05:05 AM   #5 (permalink)
Jasta 8
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Kory................errrrrrrrrrr...........sorry
 
Old 24 September 1999, 05:26 AM   #6 (permalink)
Michael Dailey
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Kory,

Here is my take on the situation for what it is worth.

Mr Constable credits McLeod with 6 victories on his web page:

1. The web page says took place on 19 Dec 1917.
This is said to be an OOC victory.

This victory is not mentioned at all in my sources which are 'The Sky Their Battlefield' and
'Royal Flying Corps Communiques 1917-1918'..


Doesn't mean it didn't happen, but it would be interesting to find out where Mr Constable got his information about this victory. My guess would be from George Drew's book 'Canada's Fighting Airmen'..

2. Is a triplane DEST according to the web page. No date is given for this victory. It is said to have occurred sometime in Jan 1918.


As far as I can tell there is no mention of a Triplane victory for Mcleod in either of my sources 'TSTB'& 'Communiques' for January.
Once again that doesn't mean it didn't happen, these two sources do not necessarily list all air victories..

3. Balloon. no date given on web page. Web page says Mcleod shot down the balloon in flames and Lt Key was Mcleods observer at the time.

'Communiques' says the date was 14 Jan 1918.
'Communiques' also says the balloon folded and fell, no mention of flames or any credit for a DEST.

This action gets no mention in TSTB.


4., 5., and 6. (VC action of 27 Mar) web page says 1 of these DEST and 2 OOC if I remember correctly.

TSTB also says 1 DEST and 2 OOC credited.

'Communiques' surprisingly does not mention the incident at all.

Mcleod's VC citation says 3 OOC.


so from my meager resources, victories 1 and 2 from the web page are not mentioned at all.

victory 3 is mentioned, but it is left in doubt as to whether the RFC credited Mcleod with a victory for this action. (Were non flamed balloons counted as victories in the RFC???)

4, 5, and 6, are mentioned almost everywhere with one notable exception.

Thus it is very possible that the RFC credited Mcleod with only 3 or 4 victories, and not six as mentioned in the web page. This may explain why he is not in the grub street publications.


Interesting side note: A. W. Hammond (Mcleod's observer) is listed in the 'Communiques' as getting 2 DEST on 18 FEB 1918 with Cpt J. Allport as his pilot (action not mentioned in TSTB).
If he got credit for these and the 3 in the 27 Mar action, he should be listed as an observer ace.


Confused now?


Regards,

MDD
 
Old 24 September 1999, 05:29 AM   #7 (permalink)
Kory Clark
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Wow, not confused at all.

I thought it might have something to do with combining Alan's Victories with those of his Observers's at the time of their death.

Thanks for the answers, makes sense.
 
 

Bookmarks

Tags
topic, question


Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are Off


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
A bit off topic question Kalt Non-WWI Aviation 1 17 November 2006 05:57 AM
Off-topic Peipus Models 5 13 January 2003 08:28 PM
Semi-Off topic question Kojack 1999 14 28 November 1999 05:45 PM
Off Topic....Need Help! Keith 1999 3 7 October 1999 08:40 AM
Way off the Topic Andrew_Smith 1999 78 15 September 1999 10:15 AM


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 02:10 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
SEO by vBSEO 3.6.0 PL2
Copyright ©1997 - 2013 The Aerodrome