|
Stephen,
You are right. Scott pays for this site, and spends his time administering it. He has every right to administer it as he sees fit. I have not always agreed with his actions, but I have no doubt that his decisions are based on what he believes are best for the forum, so that we can continue to discuss WWI aviation, and learn from people of like interests around the globe.
The Aerodrome is not a democracy, we can not override Scott's decisions by majority rule, but I trust that we are free to respectfully express our opinions.
I also believe that Manfred Thiemeyer has a lot that he could contribute to The Aerodrome. In order to participate, he would have to lay aside past grievences he has with some members, and they must do the same. Bitterness is not conducive to the "serious research" that he wants. That requires presenting facts, especially ones that contradict the conventional wisdom, in a rational and coherent manner, without personal comments that detract from the argument. If Manfred could do this, I think the Aerodrome would be a better place if Scott would lift his ban and allow him to register under his own name. The decision, of course, is Scott's.
Steven C. McCarty
|