View Single Post
Old 23 October 2009, 07:41 AM   #1 (permalink)
Hal Oele
Two-seater Pilot
 
Hal Oele's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2004
Posts: 263
 
Nieuport 17 "X" - Franklīs forgotten 8th victory?

Hi folks, dear Russ Gannon...

During my research to the R-Plane operations 1917 and 1918,
i met the relatives of the "first" pilot of R.26, who started his front-career
as a young pilot with FFA 23 in early 1916 (by the way - seven pilots and observers from FFA 23 joined between 1915 and 1917 the R-Kommando...).

In his photoalbum i found also the attached ones:

1. Wintgens victory from 2.8.1916 - Morane 5177


2. Franklīs victory from 2.8.1916 - Morane 5181


3. Franklīs victory from 3.8.1916 - Nieuport 17bis "X" 1442



So, i checked together with ManfredT some published dataīs - and now thereīs a problem!
All information from the last years, do not list the 3.8.1916.
Only US C&C 26-2 (1978) has Franklīs 7. victory listed (as a Farman?).

Jastaīs, KeK & Co are not my subject, but everytime i checked some published books there are more questionmarks as before...

Perhaps there are specialists out there who can clear this case up...

Many greetings from Bonn
Hal
Hal Oele is offline  
Sponsored Links