The Aerodrome Forum - View Single Post

10 July 2002, 02:45 AM

Speaking of questions that have gone unanswered, some that were posed in Post No.259 and repeated in Post No.280 have still not been answered. They arise from Stephen Dieter's published review of THE MAKING OF

BILLY BISHOP. To repeat:

(a) What is the passage in a periodical which he states was "severely misquoted" by Greenhouse ?

(b) To what degree does the Greenhous version differ from the original ?

© Which passages does he believe have been inadequately foot-noted ?

(d) How would he compare the level of scholarship (particularly in primary vs secondary sources) of Greenhous vs others such as McCaffrey or Bashow ?

10 July 2002, 02:45 AM	#296 (permalink)
Hugh_A._Halliday Guest Posts: n/a	Speaking of questions that have gone unanswered, some that were posed in Post No.259 and repeated in Post No.280 have still not been answered. They arise from Stephen Dieter's published review of THE MAKING OF BILLY BISHOP. To repeat: (a) What is the passage in a periodical which he states was "severely misquoted" by Greenhouse ? (b) To what degree does the Greenhous version differ from the original ? © Which passages does he believe have been inadequately foot-noted ? (d) How would he compare the level of scholarship (particularly in primary vs secondary sources) of Greenhous vs others such as McCaffrey or Bashow ?