New Mannock Biography

2 May 2008, 11:36 AM

Hi,

I was wondering how many out there know of Norman Franks and Andy Saunders new biography about

Edward Mannock due out in July?

Amazon.com: Mannock: Norman L.R. Franks, Andy Saunders: Books [US]

Amazon.co.uk: Mannock: The Life and Death of Major Edward Mannock VC, DSO, MC, RAF: Norman L.R. Franks, Andy Saunders: Books

[UK]

Regards,

Pips · 2 May 2008, 05:34 PM

Personally I think that the best book on

Mick Mannock is 'King Of The Air Fighters", by

Taffy Jones (and a very treasured possession

).

You can say what you like about Taffy's "lack of objectivity/occassional bloopers" on the subject of Mick. He has passion for the subject, he brings alive the feeling of those far off days that modern writers just can't capture. When you read the book you gain a sense of knowing Mick, feel his hatred of the Germans, his determination to keep his men alive if at all possible, his tiredness and ultimatley his sense of doom.

Norman Franks is an able and meticulous historian, he presents facts and details in a clear logical manner and covers the 'events' accurately. But like most modern historians/writers (to my mind) he lacks empathy - he lacks passion. I have no doubt that the new book will be an accurate portrayal of events surrounding Micks life and death.

But if you want to know the real Mick Mannock, search for a copy of Jones biography.

TomVrille · 3 May 2008, 05:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by wingedwarrior

I was wondering how many out there know of Norman Franks and Andy Saunders new biography about

Edward Mannock due out in July?

Hi Darren...
I hadn't heard about this book until you mentioned it! Thanks for the alert!

I've just finished reading another book that contains a good many 'Mannock anecdotes'. You might want to check out Fighter Pilot by McScotch (Lt

William Maclanachan), Mannock's good friend of while both were serving in 40 Squadron. The book provides a good close-up personal view!

3 May 2008, 06:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TomVrille

Hi Darren...
I hadn't heard about this book until you mentioned it! Thanks for the alert!

I've just finished reading another book that contains a good many 'Mannock anecdotes'. You might want to check out Fighter Pilot by McScotch (Lt

William Maclanachan), Mannock's good friend of while both were serving in 40 Squadron. The book provides a good close-up personal view!

Thanks Tom for your opinions concerning Fighter Pilot. I have been wanting to read this book for quite some time now, as I have heard a lot of good comments about it from readers. I'll have to put it on my 'to buy' list!

Regards