The Aerodrome Home Page
Aces of WWI
Aircraft of WWI
Books and Film
The Aerodrome Forum
Help
Links to Other Sites
Medals and Decorations
Search The Aerodrome
Today in History


The Aerodrome Forum


Go Back   The Aerodrome Forum > Reading Room > Aviation Personnel

Aviation Personnel Online books and articles related to WWI aviation personnel

Closed Article
 
Article Tools Display Modes
Victory Scores
Victory Scores
Barrett Tillman
Published by Barrett
29 November 1998
Victory Scores

Great Britain

During World War I the British air services (Royal Flying Corps, Royal Naval Air Service, and after 1 April 1918, the Royal Air Force) awarded a variety of victory credits for aerial combat. Because of the rare nature of air-to-air fighting in 1914-15, any successful encounter with an enemy machine was cause for notoriety. Similarly, owing to the haphazard types of weapons carried in early aircraft, a "hard kill" resulting in destruction of a hostile airplane was even rarer. Therefore, what today would be regarded as "mission kills" were considered comparable to planes destroyed or captured. Credits were given for enemy aircraft (EA) "driven down" to a lower altitude or "forced to land" behind their own lines, presumably ending their usefulness for that sortie. Later, e/a driven down and considered "out of control" (OOC) were also credited to a pilot or gunner's score.

The "forced to land" (FTL) and "driven down" (DD) credits largely disappeared in the first half of 1916, but OOCs increased. By war's end, fully 40% of all British aerial victories fell into that nebulous category.

Unlike the Germans, whose rigid rule was "one kill, one pilot," the British also allowed full credit for a shared victory -- in at least one case, nine RAF pilots received individual recognition for an OOC. Therefore, the commonly accepted tallies that have been published since 1918 provide a skewed perception of RFC/RNAS/RAF aces' scores in relation not only to other World War I air forces, but World War II as well.

The data in Table I was compiled from Above the Trenches, a Grub Street volume published in 1990. The authors are noted aero historians C.F. Shores, Norman Franks, and Russell Guest.

TABLE I
PilotTotal
Credits
Decimal
Destroyed/Captured
Canada William Bishop7255.00
England Edward Mannock6138.28
Canada Raymond Collishaw6029.20
England James McCudden5746.50
South Africa Anthony Beauchamp Proctor5433.10
Canada Donald MacLaren5423.81
Canada William Barker5040.50

Twelve other British Empire fighter pilots (Table II) achieved World War II equivalent scores of 20 or more:

TABLE II
PilotTotal
Credits
Decimal
Destroyed/Captured
Wales Ira Jones3729.13
Ireland George McElroy4728.91
England Albert Ball4428.50
Ireland Tom Hazell4327.33
Scotland John Gilmour3926.25
Australia Arthur Cobby2926.16
Canada Clifford McEwen2722.00
Canada William Claxton3721.00
Australia Robert Little4720.58
USA Francis Gillet2020.00
Australia Edgar McCloughry2120.00
England Thomas Middleton2720.00

France

According to Over the Front by Norman Franks and Frank Bailey (Grub Street, 1992) the French Air Service produced 187 aces--pilots and gunners each credited with five or more aerial victories. Of these, 159 were exclusively fighter pilots.

Like the German air service, throughout most of WWI the French credited only enemy aircraft assessed as destroyed in aerial combat or captured as a result thereof. During the early phase of the war, some nonlethal "kills" were credited, and early stars such as Roland Garros and Adolphe Pègoud received credit for both "hard" and "soft" kills. However, by early 1916 the criteria had solidified. Unlike the Germans, the Service Aeronautique granted full credit for shared victories, so it was possible for a pilot or gunner to be recognized as an ace without achieving a "solo" victory. In fact, eight French airmen did just that.

Despite the system of shared credits, the most successful French fighter pilots had few collaborative victories, and many escadrilles relied on their top scorer for the huge majority of the unit's success. In at least ten instances, the leading pilot achieved or participated in more than half the squadron victories, including Claude Haegelin who got 20 of SPA.100's 22 victories and Bernard Barny de Romanet with eight of SPA.167's ten. René Fonck was responsible for nearly two-thirds of SPA.103's tally, claiming 73 out of 111.

The following list (Table III) of the top 20 French aces shows official tallies as well as the decimal or fractional equivalent comparable to the US WWII standard.

TABLE III
PilotTotal
Credits
Decimal
Destroyed/Captured
France René Fonck7573.5
France Georges Guynemer5350.5
France Charles Nungesser4542.33
France Georges Madon4139.33
France Maurice Boyau3524.25
France Michel Coiffard3419.45
France Léon Bourjade2819.75
France Armand Pinsard2724.75
France René Dorme2323.00
France Gabriel Guérin2320.16
France Claude Haegelen2212.58
France Alfred Heurtaux2119.50
France Pierre Marinovich2118.00
France Jacques Ehrlich199.06
France Henri Hay de Slade1917.50
France Bernard Barny de Romanet1811.91
USA Raoul Lufbery1614.84
Russia Paul d'Argueff1513.50
France Armand De Turenne157.66
France Jean Sardier158.00



Closed Article

Bookmarks

Tags
victory scores, victories, scores


Article Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is On

Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Article Article Starter Category Comments Last Post
German Top Pilot Scores rammjaeger Other WWI Aviation 14 30 January 2003 02:59 PM
Authentic scores wingedwarrior People 16 21 September 2002 08:42 AM
Authentic scores wingedwarrior People 0 16 August 2002 05:46 AM
Official Scores Breguet Aircraft 0 13 July 2002 03:34 AM
Top 1918 scores Barrett 1998 2 23 December 1998 10:10 AM


As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

All times are GMT -7. The time now is 03:18 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Feedback Buttons provided by Advanced Post Thanks / Like (Lite) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2024 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
Copyright ©1997 - 2023 The Aerodrome
Article powered by GARS 2.1.9 ©2005-2006